Report: Sarah Michelle Gellar Expecting Baby No. 2

Congratulations to Sarah Michelle Gellar, 35, and Freddie Prinze, Jr., 36!

Our favorite celebrity mom is pregnant with the couple’s second child, Us Weekly reports. “She and Freddie are thrilled,” a friend of the pair tells the mag. “They’re amazing parents.”

The handsome couple met while filming the 1997 horror flick I Know What You Did Last Summer and began dating three years later. They were wed in Mexico on September 1, 2002, and welcomed daughter Charlotte Grace in September 2009.

In recent pictures, savvy Celebrity Baby Scoop readers have noticed a possible baby bump on the Buffy alum. We have the smartest fans!

Kourtney Kardashian: Mason Is “Obsessed” With Babies

Elizabeth Berkley: Pilates While Pregnant